Weekly Round-Up, 8-14 June 2022: Translation Critique, Persona Mods, and the History of Kawaii Culture


AniFem Spherical-Up

Personifying and relating to neurodiversity in Love, Chuunibyou and Other Delusions

“Center schooler illness” may not be an precise sickness, however Carmen Antreasian touches on how Takanashi Rikka’s chuuni journey resonates as a PTSD coping mechanism.

Comedic Highs and Objectified Lows: The girls of The Disastrous Life of Saiki K

At its greatest, the sequence lets its women be multifaceted and hilariously bizarre; at its worst, it sinks into drained jokes about weight and harassment that undermine its strengths.

Chatty AF 164: Dear Brother Watchalong – Episodes 32-39

The workforce mulls over the flawed ending to a strong basic.

What LGBTQ+ manga would you like to see get an anime?

The thrill from the upcoming Yuri is My Job is excessive.

Past AniFem

Dear Modders: Help Me Date All the Guys in Persona on PC (Fanbyte, Kenneth Shepard)

The doorways are open for the reason that Hashino-era video games will now be accessible on PC.

Persona has all the time had a weird relationship with queerness. And by bizarre, I imply extraordinarily shitty. Queer characters solely ever seem like the butt of jokes, even when it’s fully antithetical to its larger ethos of standing up for individuals oppressed by the system or accepting elements of your self you have been as soon as ashamed of. Regardless of that, there’s a number of romantic stress to its varied social routes, even with different males. To the purpose the place I’ve merely satisfied myself that my characters’ man mates are just real stupid and don’t notice I’m hitting on them all through their story. Joker and Ryuji are already dating in Persona 5, so far as I’m involved. However now that each one the video games are coming to PC, it could be an amazing alternative for the group to take the step Atlus has refused to over time.

The romantic arcs in Persona video games are sometimes virtually an identical to the friendship path, so it could primarily simply be a matter of tweaking some written dialogue and flags to let characters seem in sure scenes to solidify the connection. So relative to video games with extra elaborate animation and voiced dialogue, modding homosexual relationships into Persona video games can be a lightweight elevate. And actually, it’s hardly sport breaking when so a lot of these romantic relationships would really feel like pure extensions of Persona’s social parts already.

On Translation Errors & Criticism (Revue, Meru)

Musings from a working translator on frequent patterns in social media translation backlashes.

One of many feedback I see cropping up lots is that translators should not open to criticism of their work. In response to that, I’d argue that most individuals don’t know tips on how to present related, helpful criticism, or, because the French wish to say, critique.

In case you can’t learn the Japanese, I can’t in good conscience tackle board your opinion on how the Japanese needs to be interpreted. You possibly can inform me you learn the English and also you didn’t prefer it, however you’ll be able to’t inform me that it doesn’t match the Japanese. This goes for reward, too, by the way in which; somebody who doesn’t perceive Japanese telling me that I precisely mirrored the unique is very nice, but it surely’s not actionable suggestions.

Individuals like to drag out the previous “wow, are you saying I can’t complain if my burger is undercooked at McDonald’s?”, however to construct upon that metaphor, I’d say that you simply actually can, and they need to get you a recent, correctly cooked burger. However for those who go up and inform them you don’t just like the style of their burgers, what do you count on them to do? Change the recipe for you?

And to proceed with the meals analogy; we’re now at a brilliant fancy restaurant as a substitute of McDonald’s. I’m not a chef, and I don’t know a lot about cooking. I eat my meal, and I don’t actually just like the style. I can both assume “hmm, not for me” and maybe depart a overview saying it wasn’t to my tastes. Or I can go inform the chef that they suck at their job and that they’re clearly not cooking the recipe, which I’ve by no means even seen for myself, appropriately, and possibly end it off by calling for them to be fired. In situation two, I turn out to be what some individuals would possibly name an asshole.

Ghost in the Shell: SAC_2045 is a dead end of an adaptation (Polygon, Claire Napier)

A rundown of the failings of the CGI sequel to the beloved cyberpunk sequence.

In SAC_2045, Togusa is divorced. Altering such a essential a part of a personality’s identification is a daring alternative, and one which invitations questions from the viewers. If Togusa is divorced, we need to know that it’s for some goal. Why change a component with out goal, even in adaptation? In observe the reply might be that it eliminated the need for any scenes during which Part 9 has to contact Togusa’s spouse whereas he’s lacking for a number of months. However what narrative potential might exist on this artistic alternative? May this be a chance to look at Togusa’s efficiency of masculinity, each in his private {and professional} lives, and the function of masculinity within the Ghost within the Shell universe extra broadly?

In observe nonetheless, the second season of SAC_2045 removes each drop of the masculine idealism from its altered-reality radicals. Togusa’s story goes nowhere; women are foregrounded as brokers or puppets of the mysterious collective power “N” amongst a mixed-gender background. In execution, it doesn’t supply a lot to consider, regardless of the essential potential of its premise. And within the absence of an examination of masculine toxicity, there’s nothing to stability out the eerie, low-calorie misogyny the present’s creators selected to incorporate as a substitute.

Main Kusanagi is probably the most iconic character from the Ghost within the Shell franchise. However SAC_2045’s curiosity in her is as minimal because the sequence’ curiosity in any of the opposite members of Part 9, giving her no private arc, minimal interiority, and barely any episodic relevance. Her presence is felt probably the most on the finish of each episode, the place you’ll be able to take a look at her being cute as a substitute of the credit, and on the finish of the season, the place accountability for the developmental course of the human race (your complete human race) and its future falls to her. Each time an moral ultimatum falls on her, Ghost within the Shell will get slightly extra home.

The Main is changed, figuratively and actually, by a 22-year-old “moe” lady named Purin with an virtually an identical and extremely condensed boring character arc, whose compromised nudity is launched in service of drained model motifs and nothing else. There’s a “humorous” thread about her adoring Batou to the purpose of sexually harassing him that develops into an empty revelation that he rescued her as a baby after her household was murdered, and a second the place he touches her arm and feedback how her physique, now absolutely prosthetic, is “similar to” the Main’s. Stand Alone Complicated already established that Batou wishes the Main. So, what, now he’s received a “new” Main he can sleep with? Why have him contact her? Why have a battle over her earlier feedback being office sexual harassment, if that is the place they needed this to go? These artistic decisions would possibly sound innocuous to you. They don’t sound innocuous to me.

Tokyo company sells genderless school swimwear, reflecting student concerns (The Mainichi, Maki Nakajima)

The fits have trunks and a long-sleeved high, and will likely be an possibility alongside conventional college swimwear.

This yr, the genderless swimsuits are solely accessible for faculties, however the firm plans to begin promoting them to most people by its on-line retailer subsequent yr. A consultant of the corporate’s product improvement employees stated, “We hope that by carrying these swimsuits, college students will have the ability to dispel their anxiousness about swimwear, and we will assist them deal with their swimming classes in a optimistic method. And if this results in the acquisition of swimming expertise, which is the unique goal of the teachings, we might haven’t any larger pleasure than this.”

Faculty swimsuits, which was largely one-piece designs for ladies and trunks or shorts for boys, started to alter within the 2000s. In keeping with Yuko Yoshikawa of the corporate’s public relations division, long-length swimsuits that coated the thighs and two-piece swimsuits have been first launched for ladies. After this, boys’ swimsuits additionally turned longer, and in 2010, the corporate started promoting long-sleeved jackets for each women and men that would cover the higher physique and supply UV safety.

In a product improvement venture undertaken with junior highschool college students in 2015, a male scholar proposed a swimsuit with a tank-top and pants that prolonged right down to the ankles. The corporate realized that there was additionally demand from boys who additionally needed to cut back their pores and skin publicity.

Along with the need for much less publicity, the genderless swimsuits have been impressed by communication from faculties conveying the voices of youngsters with “gender dysphoria” — a distinction between the intercourse they have been registered as at beginning and the intercourse they self-identify as.

How DARLING in the FRANXX Inspired a New York Times Bestselling YA Novel (Anime Information Community, Kim Morrissy)

The origin behind Xiran Jay Zhao’s sci-fi YA novel Iron Widow.

That’s the place Iron Widow‘s plot similarities to FRANXX finish. Zhao took solely the core setup in an effort to write their very own story laser-focused on deconstructing the patriarchy. This half wasn’t notably impressed by FRANXX or any frustrations with it a lot as the broader world we dwell in.

Though some anime viewers have expressed criticisms about FRANXX‘s dealing with of gender and sexuality, Zhao stated they don’t have any main objections to FRANXX, commenting that the themes made sense inside the scope of its narrative. “I assumed it was a neat allegory for the way adults strive their hardest to cover [sexuality] from youngsters,” they remarked. “Even the blatant fanservice made sense within the context of its world, which was a part of what impressed me.”

Iron Widow, alternatively, is essentially totally different in that the youngsters are conscious of sexuality, however women are disproportionately shamed into not acknowledging it exists. The presentation is much less metaphorical and as a substitute extra direct, extra confrontational. The heroine spends a lot of the e-book angrily objecting to the double requirements she perceives. “I wouldn’t say one [style of worldbuilding] is best or worse,” Zhao stated. “I did what I personally needed to see in a narrative with a boy-girl piloting setup, which isn’t for everybody.”

‘Revue Starlight the Movie’ is the Best-Looking Film This Year (Fanbyte, Vrai Kaiser)

On the movie’s emotional closure and a missed alternative.

Revue Starlight the Film is among the most breathtaking movies I’ve seen in a protracted whereas. The duels have been all the time the spotlight of the TV sequence, however right here they’re electrifying spectacles that lovingly put on homage on their sleeves, from Adolescence of Utena to Mad Max: Fury Street to the Arcimboldo portray “Vertumnus.” Every battle seems like a brief movie unto itself, packed to the gills with particulars meant to convey the tales of every lady. The musical duets are stirring and memorable, harkening again to the genres that represented every lady within the present whereas evolving these acquainted sounds with new complexities.

The script doesn’t precisely cease mattering at these factors, but it surely turns into firmly secondary. The phrases are intoned in the identical ritualistic, repetitive manner because the historic and much-reused script of “Starlight,” much less necessary in themselves than for the historical past they join again to. In different phrases, put together to listen to the phrase “I’m occurring to my subsequent stage” a few dozen occasions. Every interlude among the many secondary solid concludes uniquely, however with a unified sense of hope. It’s finally a narrative about making an attempt once more, and studying that there’s life past highschool, and when these chords hit, they’re greater than life and tenderly honest.

There are a number of bitter notes scattered all through Revue Starlight the Film. Anybody who’s been concerned on this planet of theater is aware of that treasured few actors are in a position to make a residing from it, and whereas the script nods to each Nana and Junna having theatrical pursuits past performing on stage, they’re at greatest sidelined or at worst handled like a weak point or failing. It’s a disgrace, since anime has all the time been good about displaying the guts and fervour in seemingly unglamorous jobs, but it surely’s additionally considerably comprehensible that the script elides it provided that two-hour runtime. What lingers extra is the decision of Hikari and Karen’s battle.

How LGBTQ+ stories have evolved and flourished in manga (Popverse, Latonya Pennington)

A historic overview of yuri and BL from the basic to right now.

Along with creating Rose of Versailles, Riyoko Ikeda additionally made one other manga titled Claudine. Initially revealed in 1978, this single quantity manga is a tragic story a few transgender man named Claude residing within the twentieth century. It’s considered to be one of many earliest manga to characteristic a transgender protagonist.

One other mangaka thought-about a part of the Forty-Niners is Keiko Takemiya, who created the yaoi story In The Sunroom. Printed in 1970 within the shoujo journal Bessatsu Shoujo Comedian, the comedian can be the primary shoujo comedian to characteristic a kiss between two male characters. Whereas the comedian would finish in tragedy for the characters, it laid the groundwork for future yaoi works.

Along with works by the Forty-Niners, the social and political activism of lesbians within the ’70s would even be the roots for yuri manga. The truth is, the time period ‘yuri’, has its origins within the first formal lesbian group often called Wakakusa no Kai (Contemporary Inexperienced Membership) and Japan’s first business homosexual journal Barazoku. Each have been established in 1971, and the latter would broaden in 1976 to incorporate a web page for lesbians referred to as ‘Yurizoku no Heya’ which implies the ‘Lily Tribe’s Room’. That is the place the time period ‘yuri’ would get its identify from, each definition clever and symbolically.

In distinction, the time period ‘yaoi’ was coined within the ’80s by self-published Japanese fanzine writers Yasuko Sakata and Akiko Hatsu. Yaoi was abbreviated from the phrase ‘Yama nashi, ochi nashi, imi nashi’, which implies ‘no climax, no punch line, no that means’. Moreover, the yaoi fanzines turned often called doujinshi and started to be distributed by way of conventions reminiscent of Comiket in 1975. Within the late ’80s, the manga Patalliro can be one of many first yaoi manga to obtain an anime adaptation.

TWEET: A word of Ubukata Tow’s involvement in an upcoming Netflix sequence; Ubukata, who can even be writing the upcoming RWBY anime, was arrested on (later dropped) fees of home violence in 2015. RWBY voice actor Arryn Zechs expressed discomfort with Ubukata’s involvement as a home abuse survivor; the problem was reportedly resolved internally, with Zechs deciding to donate her cost for the sequence to charity.

THREAD: Translation of a historic picture publish of a younger Ryukyuan being shamed at school for talking his native dialect.

TWEET: Join a free lecture/panel dialogue on the emergence and significance of kawaii in women’ popular culture.

AniFem Group

We’re additionally ready for an Our Goals at Nightfall adaptation.

There's already a lot of great suggestions in the comments (Bloom Into You S2 being one of them!), but also Love After World Domination airing this season makes me long for heroine x villainess yuri sentai Superwomen In Love to receive an anime adaptation. Also I want a full length Kase-san anime rather than just the OVA it received.
Definitely Milk Morinaga's "Girl Friends". It's not only one of the best of the best yuri manga, it's never been adapted. As for studio. I would nominate: AIC (Sasameki Koto, Hourou Musuko), JC Staff (Aoi Hana), Qualia Animation (HoneyWorks' Kokuhaku series, or P.A. Works (lately, Shiroi Suna no Akuatōpu).





Source link

Leave a Comment